OneKey® MLS
  • Buy
  • Rent
  • Commercial
  • Find an Agent
  • NYS Fair Housing Notice
  • Language
    Price range
    $
    $
    Bedrooms
    Bathrooms
    Home type
    Square feet
    Lot size
    Heating
    Cooling
    Parking spots
    Garage
    Basement
    Year built
    Max HOA
    Down payment assistanceDown payment assistance
    Tours
    View
    More amenities
    1 home
      1 home available
      537 Bay 5th Street, West Islip, NY 11795
      Closed Sep 18, 2025
      537 Bay 5th Street, West Islip, NY 11795
      $780,000
      5beds
      3bath
      2,534sqft
      0.23acres
      House for Sale
      Down payment assistanceDown Payment Help

      537 Bay 5th Street, West Islip, NY 11795

      Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
      1 - 1 of 1 results
      Copyright © 2025 OneKey® MLS LLC
      Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.
      Equal opportunity
      Membio
      OneKey® MLS
      537 Bay 5th Street, West Islip, NY 11795
      Closed Sep 18, 2025
      $780,000
      Down payment assistanceDown Payment Help
      5beds
      3full,half bath
      2,534sqft
      0.23acres

      537 Bay 5th Street, West Islip, NY 11795

      City/Town:West Islip   Post Office: West Islip     

      House for Sale by Michelle SullivanDouglas Elliman Real Estate.

      Data checked -. Listing last updated 98 days ago.
      1. Overview
      2. Details
      3. More 

      This Custom-Built, Wide-Line Hi-Ranch is located in one of West Islip’s most desirable beach and boating communities. Designed for social gatherings, it features spacious living and dining room with original hardwood floors throughout. Natural light pours into the primary bedroom that includes a walk-in closet and en-suite bathroom. Two additional south-facing bedrooms on the upper level offer abundant natural light as well. The eat-in kitchen boasts quartz countertops and new flooring, with a hidden staircase leading to a sizable backyard and the lower level. The lower level includes a jumbo-sized living space with a wood-burning fireplace and sliding doors leading to the patio. Two additional bedrooms/multi-purpose rooms are perfect to accommodate your lifestyle, plus the updated full bathroom make it perfect for hosting extended family and friends. Residents have the option to join an exclusive beach association, which offers a private clubhouse on the Great South Bay, a secluded beach with spectacular views of the Robert Moses Bridge, and a boat basin with docking slips to accommodate most vessels. If you enjoy ocean beaches, boating, and leisure time in quaint villages, this peaceful home is perfect for you. It’s near to excellent restaurants, performing arts centers, seasonal farmers markets, dog park, walking/hiking trails, boutique shops and so much more. Additionally, it's convenient to hospitals and major highways. Experience South Shore living at its finest!

      Internet Serviceability
      Details
        Property type
      Residential
        Year built
      1965
        Heating
      Baseboard
        Cooling
      Central Air
        Total rooms
      9
        Garage
      Yes (1 space)
        City/Town
      West Islip
        Post Office
      West Islip
        Parking spots
      4
      883418
      MLS ID
      Closed
      Status
      Sep 18, 2025
      Closed
        Laundry features
      Inside, Laundry Room
        Flooring
      Carpet, Combination, Hardwood, Laminate
        Fireplace
      Yes
        Pets allowed
        Architectural Style
      Hi Ranch
        Basement
        View
      Neighborhood
      Interior features
      Double Vanity, Dry Bar, Eat-in Kitchen, Primary Bathroom, Quartz/Quartzite Counters, Soaking Tub, Storage, Walk-In Closet(s)
      Exterior features
      Other
      Lot features
      Back Yard, Front Yard, Landscaped, Level, Near School, Near Shops
      Appliances included
      Dryer, Electric Range, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer
      Construction materials
      Block, Brick
      Monthly taxes
      $1,551
      Yearly taxes
      $18,613.56
      Community Features
      Clubhouse, Other
      School district
      West Islip
      Schools
      Paul J Bellew Elementary School, Beach Street Middle School, West Islip Senior High School
      Senior community
      No
      Common Charges
      -
      Maintenance
      -
      Additional Fees
      -
      Fees Include
      Other
      Open Houses
      In-Person
      No upcoming in-person open houses
      Virtual
      No upcoming virtual open houses
      Contact Agent
      Michelle Sullivan
      Michelle Sullivan
      Real Estate Salesperson, Douglas Elliman Real Estate
      Direct Number 
       
      Location
      Located West of Robert Moses Causeway (RM2W) and East of Route 231 (27AE). One block West of Good Samaritan Hospital, South of Montauk Hwy. between Secatogue Lane & Center Bay Drive. Travel Montauk Hwy to Secatogue Lane, head south, proceed through the pillared entrance of Willets Point and make Left onto Bay 5th Street. House 537 is located on the Left Hand Side.
      For Sale Nearby
      No nearby homes are For Sale Nearby.
      Recently Sold
      No nearby homes have been Recently Sold.
      537 Bay 5th Street, West Islip, NY 11795, is a 5 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 2534 sqft. Single Family Residence built in 1965. This property is currently available for sale and was listed on OneKey® MLS on 8-4-2025. The MLS# for this Single Family Residence is MLS# 883418.
      Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.
      Copyright ©2025